Hiya Cris,
Your view count has probs increased drastically over the past few days and I apologise if I have contributed to such as I have been back and forth to these images. Not because I think they are bad, quite the contrary, I think they are amazing!!!
But my knowledge and experience of profile photography is limited and as such it takes me a lot longer to view an image to offer any critique. With such profile shots I like to look at the image through my own eyes first, evaluate them and then read what other more experienced portrait togs have posted (and in some cases say my say before I read the professional interpretation)
I always approach your project with a very different and unique interpretation, especially as you have defined your parameters at the beginning. So as such treat it with a certain respect.
Right, now to the nitty-gritty:
Well what can I say ... except that both images, i.e., the colour and b&w portray such a unique feel.
The colour has a certain softness about it, even though it oozes 'hardness', I think the softness is in the skin tone and eyes.
On the other hand, the b&w is 'HARD' and the edit bu 'antihero' emphasisis that even more. The edit give a more rugged, hard wearing look and the look in Katie's eyes appears more 'menacing', and the sweat drops more condusive to a good work out.
Coming to think of it ....you have your work cut out for you mate

Katie is one ACE gal and you have some major competition there ..... say no more
If I had the IT creative ability I would design an icon such as 'go Katie go! '
Cheers
Dawn
