
hmmmmm but how to combine the two????
Oh lovely image Sarah. It fits the theme nicely, although I have a really vivid picture of you hanging a bouquet of roses in the garden and applying a blow torch to them...
As for the shots. I think the second works better, making the rose more prominent an reducing the white under the glass. The only thing is you've cut the edge of the reflection off, but that's a minor niggle. The first one has too much white texture in the foreground for me.
That blow torch could have really made for an interesting shot, but I was afraid that the neighbours might have me carted away.I did see all three shots last night and agree that the highlights on the first were a problem and I like how you've fixed that with the PP. I am torn between the two edited versions though...
I do think the last has stronger composition, just a shame you've had to crop the reflection to get it.
Reshoot of Fresh Start - Excellent simple idea that I can't believe none of us thought of last week! A vast improvement on your first shot - I might have been tempted to loose some of the forgroung of the pallette but it does work as it is![]()
Ooh, I like your reshoot for Fresh Start - I agree, more Sat might help it. But brilliant Compositon etc. You take some amazing photographs!
Passion - 1st shot for me, and it is fab!![]()
I love both. Really do prefer the impact of the second, and the issue with the reflection is such a non issue I wouldn't worry about it. Great stuff from you yet again![]()
Wow, Sarah - you've been busy, and it sounds as though you've loved every minute of it.
Fresh Start - Reshoot: Great idea, my only slight niggle is a sneaking feeling that you could have changed the angle of the pallette to make better use of its lovely curves, eg tilting one side up a little, so it made more of a connection with the canvas. The composition's just a little bit disjointed for me. Sorry if that sounds really picky and mean when you've gone and done a whole new photo to replace your filler shot of the web.
Passion: I love the colour of the rose and the subtle reflection. It's a clever take on the theme, and I can quite see why you didn't torch a whole bouquet in the garden.![]()
The composition is very similar to the reshoot for Fresh Start, and I'm finding this one a bit disjointed as well. I'm really sorry, because again it's a great idea but doesn't do justice to the skills you've been showing us week in, week out. I still give you full marks, though, for the idea and having the tenacity to recrop and adjust highlights.![]()
Let's just hope that I get a bit of that magic back for you next week.Smashing pic...you are back on form!!!If I had to choose it would be no2


Colour - interesting! I'll have to come back to this one![]()
![]()

I love the PHOTO for the reshoot, but sorry the text just ruins it for meReally sorry - can we see the pic without the wording/green background? I know what you were aiming for with this, but doesn't work for me.
Water - I do likemaybe to possible have shot it from a lower angle, cos it's hard to see the water in the 'middle' bit of the spilled bits - although MORE than likely my laptop screen/angle of the screen!
Otherwise, nice shots![]()


what do you think? 



Well I like your reshoot because I totally get where you are coming from - I'm not great with the PP either so it's good to remind yourself how far you've come
Water - I'm sorry but it just lacks interest for me - probably because it's all so white. I think this could have worked better with a different BG... I'm not sure what though
Major catch up
Fresh Start reshoot: Love the concept and the execution! Very nice idea!!
Passion: #2 for me - the closer version works better imho - more intimate, more passionate! Very good
Colour reshoot: Clever - and way beyond my processing skills . Great idea and shot! I'm impressed
Water: yep a simple and elegant shot! Well lit and very theme fitting![]()
An enjoyable set of images there Sarah
Hi Sarah!
Sorry i've not found your 52 before, and what a Gem it is!![]()
some absolutely fantastic shots! I like the way you have created your own style with the dark backgrounds and high-contrast foregrounds like "mono" & "easy" . how do you go about making shots like that? do you have a little studio-type setup with a dark backdrop?
Food, exposed and grunge are also some of my favourites! well done.
looking at your recent ones; I love the passion shot, with the fire in the background it really gives a nice warm feel to the photo. fantastically done!
water: I love the composition and the white surface, but I can't help but be distracted slightly by the edges of the green border. maybe that's just mewhat do you think?
"colour" shot is good. I also prefer it without the text, but see that it is slightly blurry.
I hope you don't mind, but the EXIF says it was shot at 1/10" with ISO200. Maybe it would have been better moving it somewhere a bit lighter and using a higher shutter speed, with maybe a ISO400? it would have far more impact. again, tell me what you think...
I think that you original colour shot with the Rubix cube is far better IMHO. Infact, it is probably my favourite (i'm an 80's child)
I look forward to following your 52. some great shots! nice work!![]()
water : simple yet effective...
only comment to make is that I feel like the glass reflection at the bottom of the frame is too tight to the border, especially with the blank space at the top...just a minor niggle though...
![]()
Colour, love the strawbs... not sure about the text... maybe a bit much for me... and covers too much of the image underneath..
Water, I like it, and you've caught the water well. Nice and simple.
I like your colour shot - different!!
Water, sometimes the best shots are the simplest ones, and this is spot on for me![]()
Hey Sarah - you've been a busy girl.
I think anybody doing reshoots is brave. I haven't managed a single one yet.
Reshoot of Colour: I love this.Yes, it's bright, in-your-face and, imo, great fun. Lovely and a million miles away from your Rubik's cube (which was ok, btw
) Well done on the Photoshop work involved in it, too. You must be really chuffed with how that's going.
Reshoot of Water: What a contrast between these two.This is so simple (visually - not to set up!) understated and elegant. You rose to the challenge - and conquered. Well done.
Jean
it could still work with a different colour and a slightly transparent lettering...

Major catch upand for me too!
Fresh Start reshoot: Love the concept and the execution! Very nice idea!! Brilliant idea, great composition too.
Passion: #2 for me - the closer version works better imho - more intimate, more passionate! Very goodI like #1 but I
#
Colour reshoot: Clever - and way beyond my processing skills . Great idea and shot! I'm impressedand mine too
Water: yep a simple and elegant shot! Well lit and very theme fittingNot my favourite but well done nonetheless.
An enjoyable set of images there Sarah![]()
Hi Sarah...I'm not sure about the colour shot, I'm in to minds the idea is a good one but it just don't work with the green and such bold letters...it could still work with a different colour and a slightly transparent lettering...
Water it's a good idea again but blends in to the background a little to much for me...still good though...![]()
The reshoot for fresh start is an excellent and original take on the theme![]()
Passion i prefer part 2, using the open fire for the b/g was a fantastic idea
Love the use of the writing in the colours reshoot and water is a fantastic idea![]()

Lovely set of pictures, and you are learning so quickly too. Well done Sarah

Don't be so hard on yourself - this is the best Out of Context shot I've seen so far!
Great idea - ok maybe the lighting could use a bit of work but it's got everything else going for it. Great choice of background.
I know what you mean about making excuses and feeling like you're not moving forwards but we're in the home straight now. I think we all need a bit of a boost having done this for 41 weeks now. I have no idea how people make it to the end of a 365...
That's very good! And I'll have to agree, it's photographically the best of us so far! Nice one![]()
Sarah - I hope you're feeling better.
Your idea for Out of Context is excellent, and I also think you've been a bit hard on yourself over it. But, then, that's the sort of attitude that's taken your photography up a good number of notches in the time you've been doing this Challenge. Look back over the whole thread, rather than just an odd week or two, because the trend is month-on-month improvement. If there are any blips, you've learned from them, and a seasoned pro would be proud of some of the stuff you've posted.
Jean





