Canon 50mm f1.8 (with adapter) vs 40mm f2.4

penny2611

Suspended / Banned
Messages
3
Edit My Images
No
I'm quite new to photography, and i own a 50mm f1.8 lens, the nifty fifty. For a holiday trip, i wish to be able to take photos of my friends (group shots) and I find the canon 50mm f1.8 to be "zoomed" on my 600D. Should I get a wide-angle adapter for my lens(like the one on photojojo) or the 40mm f2.8, or any other walk around lenses that you can recommend? I'm looking for a small and portable lens. I'm on a tight budget and not really willing to spend much considering I have a zoom lens(from the kit lens) which is quite bulky for my travel.
 
hi penny why not use the kit lens in manual at the 17mm end thats if its a 17-55 mm kit lens and arange your friends so there all in the frame
 
Yes, Canon 18-55 kit zoom is the obvious answer. Very versatile walkabout lens, can tackle anything from portraits to landscapes, and great value.

40mm will not be very different to 50mm.
 
hi penny why not use the kit lens in manual at the 17mm end thats if its a 17-55 mm kit lens and arange your friends so there all in the frame

It's a 18-135mm lens, a bit too bulky to be carried around. Would a wide angle converter on the 50mm lens work?

Yes, Canon 18-55 kit zoom is the obvious answer. Very versatile walkabout lens, can tackle anything from portraits to landscapes, and great value.

40mm will not be very different to 50mm.

Do you recommend other lenses? Or ways to make the 50mm less zoomed?
 
It's a 18-135mm lens, a bit too bulky to be carried around. Would a wide angle converter on the 50mm lens work?

Wide-angle adapters are not great :thumbsdown:

Do you recommend other lenses? Or ways to make the 50mm less zoomed?

If compact size and affordable cost are priorities, then the 18-55 kit zoom is going to be hard to beat. But obviously duplicates most of your 18-135 range, which might be quite big, but it's not very heavy.

What's your budget?
 
Wide-angle adapters are not great :thumbsdown:

If compact size and affordable cost are priorities, then the 18-55 kit zoom is going to be hard to beat. But obviously duplicates most of your 18-135 range, which might be quite big, but it's not very heavy.

What's your budget?

About 400? I'm not really keen on carrying the 18-135 because I'll be on the go, and wouldn't want to carry too bulky items. The 50mm would have been a good choice but the crop sensor on the 600D makes the view really zoomed, i was hoping the 40mm would have been a better choice
 
About 400? I'm not really keen on carrying the 18-135 because I'll be on the go, and wouldn't want to carry too bulky items. The 50mm would have been a good choice but the crop sensor on the 600D makes the view really zoomed, i was hoping the 40mm would have been a better choice

If you want to see what a 40mm angle of view looks like, put your 18-135mm lens on the camera and set the zoom ring to 40mm (or there abouts). It gives a slightly wider view than the 50mm but not by much. Maybe a used 28mm lens would be more appropriate, and would be within your budget.
 
About 400? I'm not really keen on carrying the 18-135 because I'll be on the go, and wouldn't want to carry too bulky items. The 50mm would have been a good choice but the crop sensor on the 600D makes the view really zoomed, i was hoping the 40mm would have been a better choice

Set your 18-135 to 40mm, compare to 50mm, and see if that's wide enough for you. If so, then the 40mm a great little lens and there's nothing else quite like it. In terms of bulk/weight, kit 18-55 zoom comes closest.

Or consider buying another travel camera, ie a compact. Very portable and versatile, at the expensive of some image quality (may be less than you think ;)). That's probably what I'd do from what you've said, and lots of good options out there.

Edit: crossed post with Simon
 
ok how many friends are we talking in the picture at 1 time this would give us a idea if you could get away with the 50mm if you arrange them in a certain order and stand futher back
 
40mm will be the smallest lens you can get but as mentioned, it won't be too different from the 50mm
 
Buy a cheap 18-55 MKII lens. Can pick them up for a bargain price and they are very light!
 
Back
Top