Which Sharpening Technique?....

RedRobin

Dances With Dogs
Suspended / Banned
Messages
9,425
Name
Robin
Edit My Images
Yes
I'm a beginner to DSLR and shoot RAW and upload to Aperture 3.5.1 (latest version) where I may fine-tune.

From there as a final step I edit any sharpening of the image as a TIFF 16-bit in Photoshop CS6 (opened from within Aperture) and can either sharpen using....

A) - Filter > Sharpen > Unsharp Mask...

Or

B) - Filter > Other > High Pass... Layer > Overlay > Hard Light / Soft Light / %

The High Pass technique seems to have more subtle control on the result but I wondered which technique most toggers here would recommend, please, including any additional methods.

Thanks :)
 
I tend to use Smart Sharpen and/or High Pass Filter in most cases, though with Photoshop CC the option of Shake Reduction can be very useful indeed.
 
W O W !! Thankyou Chris :thumbs:

Both those links are extremely helpful, especially the tutorial example as my signature shows I am very keen on photographing Dragonflies.
 
Seems to be a common problem that people spend a huge amount of £'s on the most complicated editing software when starting out :thinking:
 
I use LAB sharpening for many of mine, quite simply add it as an action and it is even easier.

 
I tend to use Smart Sharpen and/or High Pass Filter in most cases, though with Photoshop CC the option of Shake Reduction can be very useful indeed.

....My Photoshop CS6 doesn't have a Shake Reduction option :(

However, according to Adobe's video, it shouldn't be used on dark background images or noisy ones.

Thanks for posting this info, gramps - Appreciated
:)
 
Seems to be a common problem that people spend a huge amount of £'s on the most complicated editing software when starting out :thinking:

....Which editing software were you referring to, Neil?
 
... my signature shows I am very keen on photographing Dragonflies.

I photograph mainly invertebrates and flowers. This sort of thing - invertebrates - flowers. These images were captured over several years with several cameras (3 bridge cameras, one P&S and one micro-four thirds), and originally processed using the techniques I was using at the time. Because I wanted to compare the results from these cameras and wanted as level a playing field as I could achieve, I reprocessed them all recently using my current techniques. I do sometimes use different techniques (e.g. creative sharpening in Lightroom) for some other types of photographs, but given your interest in dragonflies I'm concentrating here on the techniques I use for the vast majority of my stuff - invertebrates and flowers.

I have tried various sharpening techniques over the past six years or so, but have settled (at least for the moment :) ) on using Photoshop Smart Sharpen (in CS2). I do most of my processing in Lightroom (version 5), and don't do any sharpening in Lightroom; so I do no input sharpening and no creative sharpening. The only sharpening I do is output sharpening.

I sharpen after resizing to the final output size (currently 1100 pixels high).

I usually use the smallest Radius which produces any perceptible result (to my eye), which is 0.3 pixels. Sometimes, particularly with snails and slugs, I may use a larger Radius. (This is not to do with the shells, it is to do with the way their bodies - if that is the word - respond to sharpening.)

I use Amounts varying from about 20% to about 100%.

I also use sharpening-related techniques such as defogging/clarity (USM with small Amount, large Radius and Zero Threshold), and also Clarity in Lightroom. I usually use a very mild (indeed, scarcely perceptible) application of these techniques. (e.g. I have a very mild defog built into my workflow, just before the output sharpening, of USM Amount 7%, Radius 30 pixels, Threshold 0. If you try this you will see what I mean by "mild". :) )

I don't print much, but when I do (usually A4, occasionally 16x12) I prepare a version for on-screen viewing to get the look that I want, then I revert the sharpening and the downsizing, and then sharpen the full size image using Smart Sharpen with the same Amount and twice the radius.
 
....My Photoshop CS6 doesn't have a Shake Reduction option :(

However, according to Adobe's video, it shouldn't be used on dark background images or noisy ones.

Thanks for posting this info, gramps - Appreciated
:)

Shake reduction can have some unwanted effects if used incorrectly :)
 
Thankyou, Nick - That's a very full and comprehensive How-To and I appreciate you spending time writing it all out. I shall have to give it a go.

I don't have Lightroom but have Aperture and never touch its Sharpening controls but usually Definition and Details.
 
I shall have to give it a go.

And the other techniques mentioned here too I hope. What works best really does vary greatly from person to person, and also for me at least from time to time. As I learn of new (to me) techniques I like to experiment with them to see if they will work for me, as is or in some modified form, and that way my toolkit changes from time to time. (And occasionally it changes in big ways, two examples for me being when someone (here actually) convinced me to have a serious go at using RAW, and also when I experimented with using a white/grey card. Starting to use Lightroom was a bit of a game-changer for me too.)
 
I use LAB sharpening for many of mine, quite simply add it as an action and it is even easier.


....I very much like the simplicity of this method. It's also very logical. Thanks :thumbs:
 
For butterflies and dragonflies I did the following, which seemed to work.

Used DPP to add unsharp mask to the RAW file. Then transferred to Photoshop. Increased pixel size to required amount. Copied the layer, used the high-pass filter, with a suitable number (15 px-35px). Set the layer overlay to soft light. Masked out everything, then drew over the veins etc. with a white brush, ~20px, soft edges, 30% flow (I have a pressure sensitive tablet).
 
Have play with this, it looks complex but its quite easy when you get the hang of it

http://www.earthboundlight.com/phototips/photoshop-really-smart-sharpening.html?search=edge mask&bool=and

Also a tutorial link about it which I hope is OK to post

http://photography-on-the.net/forum/showthread.php?p=13207078#post13207078


Thanks Chris... that one passed me by. Looks useful for some older images I have never managed to be satisfied with. I'll give that a go... looks promising.
 
Back
Top