Should doctors strike?

Really, comparing a waste process worker and a doctor? Not sure how many sewer workers are responsible for life and death on a day to day basis.

Easy to say they have it easy, but when you need these people do you not want them to be committed and well looked after so they put 100% into the job? Doctors are the people all of us need at some point. I am happy to see them rewarded for their work, and think nurses etc should also be given a pay rise.

You referred to them being up to their elbows in blood and guts like that was one of the reasons they should be paid the high salary.

And waste process workers and sewer workers work in an environment that one lung full of the dangerous gasses produced in what they do and they're dead so they do make life affecting decisions on a daily basis. You could say they chose to do that job, so did doctors.

I'd want a doctor to put 100% into his job regardless of his salary as said by the one's in defence of the doctors, they're not in it for the money. If he's not putting 100% into his job he's not a doctor he's a prat with a certificate.

Flash in the pan
Nice generalisation of cleaners you made there, says a lot about you. Unfortunately not everyone gets the opportunity for a good education, they may indeed be as clever as the doctors and well educated people of this country but never had the opportunity to further their education.
 
That's nice. You should try being a doctor in this day and age. My next rotation is acute med/A&E. That means 12 days of 9-5 (though I'll be in at 8 every day, and out at 7 if I'm lucky) with two days off. For that, I'm paid less than my friend, who's an optometrist and works a steady 5 day 9-5 and has been working (and getting paid) for three years longer than me. Oh, and with the new EU working hours laws, we don't get paid overtime either. Also, from the 6 years of study I did I still have 30k+ of debt to pay off.

Let's get rid of this myth that doctors are paid loads and do no work. Yes it's a well paid job, but many of the doctors I know are also the hardest workers I know of anyone in any job (nurses aside!), and for the first 5-6 years of being a doctor you are paid a pittance for what you do. People don't become doctors for the money. If you do, you quickly leave after the first couple of years. You're in it because you enjoy the work.

That said I don't agree with the strike, but I think doctors should be paid a substantial pension. I also think that teachers and nurses should be paid a lot more but it's public money...so what can you do :suspect:.

This is quite at odds with the doctors I know, who are obscenely well paid. I know two anesthetists who get paid stupid amounts of money, and neither of them have even completed their consultancy exams yet.

I was on an NCT class last week, attending with my partner, and we got talking to a GP (also on the class) who is currently renting in Holland Park. £4k a month.

While I utterly respect the work doctors do, I find it a bit tiring when I hear them lamenting how hard they work, as if the rest of society have their feet up in the coffee room drawing glasses on the Page 3 girls..

Compared to the rest of the working world, you have a job that pays and provides the potential for indescribable privilege, and nobody should feel sorry for any of you.

Try working on a checkout in Tesco; you'd have something to moan about in 2012.
 
Last edited:
This is quite at odds with the doctors I know, who are obscenely well paid. I know two anesthetists who get paid stupid amounts of money, and neither of them have even completed their consultancy exams yet.

I was on an NCT class last week, attending with my partner, and we got talking to a GP (also on the class) who is currently renting in Holland Park. £4k a month.

While I utterly respect the work doctors do, I find it a bit tiring when I hear them lamenting how hard they work, as if the rest of society have their feet up in the coffee room drawing glasses on the Page 3 girls..

Compared to the rest of the working world, you have a job that pays and provides the potential for indescribable privilege, and nobody should feel sorry for any of you.

Try working on a checkout in Tesco; you'd have something to moan about in 2012.

I find it difficult to begrudge Drs the money they earn for the majority they do a god job having completed at least a medical degree plus 5 years (min) post grad training. I also know what could be earned totally in private sector, or by taking one of the other routes available to them (insurance or pharmaceuticals for example)

But,, for all the daily mail comments etc etc, this seems more about having the goalposts moved again then anything else. Remember all NHS pensions were renogatiated only two years ago
 
I find it difficult to begrudge Drs the money they earn for the majority they do a god job having completed at least a medical degree plus 5 years (min) post grad training. I also know what could be earned totally in private sector, or by taking one of the other routes available to them (insurance or pharmaceuticals for example)

But,, for all the daily mail comments etc etc, this seems more about having the goalposts moved again then anything else. Remember all NHS pensions were renogatiated only two years ago

Same here, I don't begrudge doctors a penny of their earnings. They work ridiculously long in their studies and they perform a highly skilled job. They should be awarded accordingly.

Again, though, and I forgot to mention in the previous post.. Doctors think they're the only ones who work long hours, but strangely, seem to think they're the only ones who're in debt.

Same with lawyers. Both seem to moan about being £30k in debt. My girlfriend's a solicitor, and I've heard her friends give the same moan. Well, you earn £100,000+ a year for an American corporation. The average wage is £20k, so that's the equivalent of someone being £6k in debt, which is a lot less than what most people are. It's all relative, but the middle classes pretend they're the only ones who're squeezed.
 
Last edited:
London Headshots said:
Again, though, and I forgot to mention in the previous post.. Doctors think they're the only ones who work long hours, but strangely, seem to think they're the only ones who're in debt.

I've never met one who thinks that...
 
No, you didn't miss the bit, you missed the point. Entirely.

No, I didn't. If those who work on the tills at Tesco feel aggrieved then they too have the right to withhold or restrict their labour, that's the beauty of living in a free, democratic society...
 
I must have missed the bit about all university and post-grad training that's required to sit behind a till and pass things over a scanner....

thats known as a "fine arts degree" isnt it :lol:
 
they too have the right to withhold or restrict their labour, that's the beauty of living in a free, democratic society...

Unlike policemen or forces personel who don't , and get paid less than doctors for doing a substantially more hazardous job.

Personally I don't think anyone should be striking ,its an outmoded concept and harms joe public far more than it does the decision makers (look at the miners strike - what did that actually acheive ? )

And before anyone starts with the "oh woe is me, you wouldnt say that if it happened to you" garbage - I used to work for a natural england funded project and it happened to me in 2010 - we had a 23% budget cut and were told that our supposedly permanent contracts might not be funded in the next financial year... I didnt take part in the unison strikes as I realised they would be completely pointless and voted with my feet instead and got a job in the private sector instead.

Which is the bottom line as far as i'm concerned , don't like being a doctor (or council worker, teacher, tanker driver, or whatever) then fine do something else.
 
No, I didn't. If those who work on the tills at Tesco feel aggrieved then they too have the right to withhold or restrict their labour, that's the beauty of living in a free, democratic society...

No, you really did miss the point, since it was me who was making it, I think that makes me the authority on what the point is. I'm not talking about striking, otherwise I'd have mentioned striking. If you work n a job that doesn't forbid striking by law, then you have the right to strike. This shouldn't even be a topic of debate. Even then I use the term "right" as loosely as possible, since they also have the right to strike even if it's against the law.

The point I was making was that one is a **** job and one isn't, and in the current climate, only one person out of the two have the right to make lamentations.
 
Last edited:
Not sure he did. You compared working on a checkout to being a doctor. If you think working at tesco is hard, try working in a brothel in 2012.:bonk:

I didn't compare to two, quite the opposite, I outlined the distinction between them.
 
both have the 'right' as in freedom of speech , but only one can expect the majority of joe public not to treat their whining with derision
 
No grudges mate. Yes you get on my tits sometime, but that's forums..
Funnillt enough, on another thraed I was just going to remark what a good point you made...
If these people are able to identify where they're going wrong, and still struggling, the problem isn't the industry, it's them.

IE went down and I ended back on 'My Posts' and came back here.

Oh well..
 
jimmyb said:
Flash in the pan
Nice generalisation of cleaners you made there, says a lot about you. Unfortunately not everyone gets the opportunity for a good education, they may indeed be as clever as the doctors and well educated people of this country but never had the opportunity to further their education.

THIS

How do you expect to attract Doctors from various backgrounds?

This is the reason they put themselves through debt, long training, multiple unsocial hours at work. If all changes, as planned by the government, will we get the same variety? I had the fortune of seeing a wonderful doctor who was the first in her family to go to university, and the daughter of a milkman (no jokes!). She has a mountain of debt, as do a lot of people I know, but she loves her job and seems to be good at it. It would be tragic if we lose this calibre of doctor because of reduced opportunity.
 
gramps said:
'Elective' = non-emergency, includes hip replacement, knee replacement, cataract, hernia and many more. Preventing these operations taking place causes direct harm to those suffering.

It isn't my responsibility to formulate a viable option, except to say if it affects a patient adversely, don't do it! Do not hold patients to ransom in an effort to increase your already substantial income.

They're not wanting to increase their income are they??

Are you stating that these non emergency cases are being completely scrapped?
 
Flash in the pan
Nice generalisation of cleaners you made there, says a lot about you. Unfortunately not everyone gets the opportunity for a good education, they may indeed be as clever as the doctors and well educated people of this country but never had the opportunity to further their education.

Uch well, why didn't you say that? How should we sort this, pay the cleaners £100k or the doctors £10k?

citizensmith_396x222.jpg
 
London Headshots said:
No, you really did miss the point, since it was me who was making it, I think that makes me the authority on what the point is. I'm not talking about striking, otherwise I'd have mentioned striking. If you work n a job that doesn't forbid striking by law, then you have the right to strike. This shouldn't even be a topic of debate. Even then I use the term "right" as loosely as possible, since they also have the right to strike even if it's against the law.

The point I was making was that one is a **** job and one isn't, and in the current climate, only one person out of the two have the right to make lamentations.

Slightly insulting to those who work on the checkouts. Unless of course you meant that being a doctor was a **** job?
 
Johnd2000 said:
Good point, and precisely the reason why they should be well rewarded. I don't want my GP to have to top up his income with private work (or worse by taking drug co and service provider "incentives"). NHS pay rates need to be sufficient to mitigate the risk that patient care decisions become less clinical and more financial. GP commissioning is likely to increase that risk, so hitting pay/pensions at the same time is complete madness.

One of the most compelling arguments and the real scary change - commissioning.
 
Okay, there is some real **** being spouted here. I'll let you in on my background a bit, I'm only 19 but would say I have a fair experience of the NHS having worked there for a year and pretty much all my family works in the NHS in various medical and admin roles. Last year I applied to study medicine but didn't get in because for the 110 places available there were 4000 applicants and I just wasn't good enough. This was after working my arse off in every exam since I was 11-12 because I knew what I wanted to do. So that's 6-7 years of working as hard as possible through school to hit the top grades required to even have the opportunity to apply. Then if you are lucky enough to get a place at medical school you then have 5-6 years at University where every year you have to work, unlike most courses where the first year is a bit of a doss.

After the 11-12 years you then have another 2 foundation years earning salaries LESS than some of the Nurses on the wards etc where you are working. For me that's fair because without nurses the NHS would fall apart at the seams but you don't go in earning £80k

So that's 13 years worth of extremely hard work to be earning 27k. It then probably takes 5-10 years to be earning anywhere near the figures that are being spouted out by some on here. If anyone can name another job that requires that amount of time and dedication to achieve I am all ears.

Now from my experience of working from inside the NHS, on an more admin side of things, working in A&E and on the wards. I would see doctors working 2-3hrs past their finishing time handing over patients REGULARLY whilst not being paid. I would also see doctors having to resuscitate babies, children, adults and old age people knowing that the person's life is in their hands. How often does Mr.Car Sales Exec have to resuscitate a 5 year old child whilst its parents are crying only meters away?

Then you have the actual admin side of things. I don't think anybody who comes from the private sector would believe how inefficient the NHS is run. Being on the bottom rung of the ladder I had 5 levels of managers just to get to directorate manager, who coincidentally was earning £80K+ more than probably 99% of the medical staff.
 
Erm....right...because medicine is the only profession where people work hard! Really, starting from the age of 11 when counting the number of years to qualify is just utterly laughable. Ditto the 'resuscitating babies' rubbish. It's your job, don't like it, don't do it. My other half is a (paeds) nurse and admits while when something goes badly it can be tragic, but doing a real job where most of the time you are really helping people directly is worth it. Incidentally, the government paid her way through uni, came out qualified with no debt and earns a decent wage. A close family member is a doctor in his early 30's and is earning comfortably more than most people I know in various industries (there's even some who work longer than 9-5!!)

Fact of the matter is that the public service pension system is effectively bankrupt. There will have to be huge cuts to pensions right across the board in future. Tough.

It's your fault for making people live longer :P
 
Last edited:
Now from my experience of working from inside the NHS, on an more admin side of things, working in A&E and on the wards. I would see doctors working 2-3hrs past their finishing time handing over patients REGULARLY whilst not being paid. I would also see doctors having to resuscitate babies, children, adults and old age people knowing that the person's life is in their hands. How often does Mr.Car Sales Exec have to resuscitate a 5 year old child whilst its parents are crying only meters away?

Then you have the actual admin side of things. I don't think anybody who comes from the private sector would believe how inefficient the NHS is run.

Beginning of this week, one of my work colleagues died of a massive heart attack, he just fell of his chair in front of everyone whislt on a training course, one of his work mates (a first aider) performed cpr until the works medical team and then the ambulance crew arrived. Sadly he could not be resuscitated.
My point is, don't presume a car dealer may never be in a position where he may have to try to resuscitate someone, if he does, he won't even be paid a salary to do so.
The few times I have just been to hospital to visit someone or take someone for an appointment is all the proof I need to know the NHS is inefficient and probably why the doctors work past their official finishing time.
 
mid_gen said:
Erm....right...because medicine is the only profession where people work hard! Really, starting from the age of 11 when counting the number of years to qualify is just utterly laughable. Ditto the 'resuscitating babies' rubbish. It's your job, don't like it, don't do it. My other half is a (paeds) nurse and admits while when something goes badly it can be tragic, but doing a real job where most of the time you are really helping people directly is worth it. Incidentally, the government paid her way through uni, came out qualified with no debt and earns a decent wage. A close family member is a doctor in his early 30's and is earning comfortably more than most people I know in various industries (there's even some who work longer than 9-5!!)

Fact of the matter is that the public service pension system is effectively bankrupt. There will have to be huge cuts to pensions right across the board in future. Tough.

It's your fault for making people live longer :P

I dont think anyone has ever claimed it is.

Btw the nhs pension pot is £2bn in the black. That's not effectively bankrupt. The point is about moving the goalposts again. It's only.been two years since nhs pensions were last renegotiated
 
There seem to be two types of comment on this thread. Those who have some experience of the situation or have researched the "facts"; and those who don't know much about the deeper issues (or even the more superficial ones). Both are obviously valid.

I think doctors do a good job in constrained conditions.

Agreed that striking is less than ideal. However, it's the only method of protest they have. The decision apparently was not taken lightly. They are (apparently) well educated, intelligent people. They are still carrying out the essential work. They also must have had some idea how some of the public may view the industrial action and yet these well educated, intelligent people still thought it was imperative to do.

Makes you wonder why? As I've said before my belief is that this is the proverbial straw that broke the camel's back. The pension was very recently renegotiated. Now the goalposts are being shifted. They're not asking for more money. Then add in the potential disaster of commissioning.

The people who I have spoken to who are doctors have had a constant shifting in goalposts. This is the real issue.

It's hard not to be emotive about the work the doctors do. My nan being on the intensive care unit for a month with the doctors making life and death decisions constantly. It really is more than just their job. Which is the way we'd all want it.

S
 
Last edited:
I stopped reading this half way through page 7. I say keep all your monies in a big pink piggy bank! Government can't tell you how much to put in, how much to take out, when to take It out or that your not entitled to half of it.

xxx
 
Erm....right...because medicine is the only profession where people work hard! Really, starting from the age of 11 when counting the number of years to qualify is just utterly laughable.

You may think that...but when applying for a place at some universities applicants without 7-8 A*s at GCSE were automatically discarded regardless of A Levels, Work Experience, Personal Statement etc. To get 7-8 A*s at GCSE requires hard work from the first years of high school (age 11-12). Like I said when you have 4000 applicants applying for 110 places and more every year the entrance requirements get harder and harder and the admissions officers start looking earlier and earlier into your education. Trust me...it sounds laughable...it is laughable...but if you want to do it, thats the way it is.

Beginning of this week, one of my work colleagues died of a massive heart attack, he just fell of his chair in front of everyone whislt on a training course, one of his work mates (a first aider) performed cpr until the works medical team and then the ambulance crew arrived. Sadly he could not be resuscitated.

I'm sorry to hear that, and it is something completely out of the ordinary. Perhaps I should have phrased it as 'on a fairly regular basis'

The few times I have just been to hospital to visit someone or take someone for an appointment is all the proof I need to know the NHS is inefficient and probably why the doctors work past their official finishing time.

If you saw how much paperwork etc a doctor has to fill out you can understand why it takes so long. On the wards I see doctors filling out patients notes and discharge letters etc more than actually seeing patients, and thats wrong
 
Slightly insulting to those who work on the checkouts. Unless of course you meant that being a doctor was a **** job?

How can you presume to know the personal feelings of an infinite variety of people working a single role? You can't.

A decent job is based on the potential for growth, the variety and challenge of the work involved, the qualifications and skill needed to perform it, the respect that the job earns you, how much the job earns, and finally, how much the employer respects you for doing it.

Working on a checkout scores a 0 in all of them. Thus, it's a **** job.

That doesn't mean the people on the checkouts are ****. I worked on a checkout for a year when I was 18, so I'm speaking from personal experience.
 
Why do I get a horrible feeling of de ja vu reading through this thread.

We've been here before several times, just replace doctors with teachers or nurses or public sector workers. It's been done to death.

Given the OP was involved in most of those, don't really know why he raised this subject again...
 
Okay, there is some real **** being spouted here. I'll let you in on my background a bit, I'm only 19 but would say I have a fair experience of the NHS having worked there for a year and pretty much all my family works in the NHS in various medical and admin roles. Last year I applied to study medicine but didn't get in because for the 110 places available there were 4000 applicants and I just wasn't good enough. This was after working my arse off in every exam since I was 11-12 because I knew what I wanted to do. So that's 6-7 years of working as hard as possible through school to hit the top grades required to even have the opportunity to apply. Then if you are lucky enough to get a place at medical school you then have 5-6 years at University where every year you have to work, unlike most courses where the first year is a bit of a doss.

After the 11-12 years you then have another 2 foundation years earning salaries LESS than some of the Nurses on the wards etc where you are working. For me that's fair because without nurses the NHS would fall apart at the seams but you don't go in earning £80k

So that's 13 years worth of extremely hard work to be earning 27k. It then probably takes 5-10 years to be earning anywhere near the figures that are being spouted out by some on here. If anyone can name another job that requires that amount of time and dedication to achieve I am all ears.

Now from my experience of working from inside the NHS, on an more admin side of things, working in A&E and on the wards. I would see doctors working 2-3hrs past their finishing time handing over patients REGULARLY whilst not being paid. I would also see doctors having to resuscitate babies, children, adults and old age people knowing that the person's life is in their hands. How often does Mr.Car Sales Exec have to resuscitate a 5 year old child whilst its parents are crying only meters away?

Then you have the actual admin side of things. I don't think anybody who comes from the private sector would believe how inefficient the NHS is run. Being on the bottom rung of the ladder I had 5 levels of managers just to get to directorate manager, who coincidentally was earning £80K+ more than probably 99% of the medical staff.

Ok you have little experience in the NHS, and its quite obvious.

The first couple of years of med school can be a doss, you are not working clinically for a while, and the placements you do are not exactly difficult.

As for junior doctors getting paid less than "some" ward staff, is they have less responsibility and are pretty clueless. Look at the figures for patient poor outcomes, yes every year when the new House officers start or the new name for them, it gets worse, thats a fact. Some ward nurses have worked years to get where they are at so a day one, week one baby doctor should not get as much as a senior nurse. Nurses on the wards, assess treat, prescribe and discharge. Some specialist nurses are even on the Doctors rota!!! There is an adage of "be nice to nurses, they stop Doctors killing you"

Resuscitation of a 5 yr old, well to be honest Doctors are not the best at running resuscitations, how many Doctors are on a hospitals Resus training teams... hmm that will be none. As nurses and other health care professionals are quite capable of doing ALS, ATLS, PALS etc.
The reason handovers take long times is 2 fold, one the junior docs admin is usually up his arse, they are short staffed and won't speak out (as its still very much a kiss arse jobs for the boys/girls promotion structure). So really they have a hand in it. They do claim overtime/time back and take it!!! Nurses also regularly work over.

I am sorry but lots of people do it for the money, and or social status, rather than the patient. Ask a doctor what the "hip replacement in bed 4" is called, bet you they don't know, why, because actually they are not interested in the patient. A lot of my colleagues especially surgeons do it for their own gratification, there attitude is look how good my surgery is, look what I have done for you. Most would also rather do a private session as spend time at home with their kids, why? greed for more money.

Please don't come the oh its a hard life, its not, I have never seen a poor doctor with all those student debts, thats just laughable.

Saying that, I agree that the pension was something that went with the job and no one should start changing terms and conditions years down the line.
 
Ok you have little experience in the NHS, and its quite obvious.

The first couple of years of med school can be a doss, you are not working clinically for a while, and the placements you do are not exactly difficult.

As for junior doctors getting paid less than "some" ward staff, is they have less responsibility and are pretty clueless. Look at the figures for patient poor outcomes, yes every year when the new House officers start or the new name for them, it gets worse, thats a fact. Some ward nurses have worked years to get where they are at so a day one, week one baby doctor should not get as much as a senior nurse. Nurses on the wards, assess treat, prescribe and discharge. Some specialist nurses are even on the Doctors rota!!! There is an adage of "be nice to nurses, they stop Doctors killing you"

Resuscitation of a 5 yr old, well to be honest Doctors are not the best at running resuscitations, how many Doctors are on a hospitals Resus training teams... hmm that will be none. As nurses and other health care professionals are quite capable of doing ALS, ATLS, PALS etc.
The reason handovers take long times is 2 fold, one the junior docs admin is usually up his arse, they are short staffed and won't speak out (as its still very much a kiss arse jobs for the boys/girls promotion structure). So really they have a hand in it. They do claim overtime/time back and take it!!! Nurses also regularly work over.

I am sorry but lots of people do it for the money, and or social status, rather than the patient. Ask a doctor what the "hip replacement in bed 4" is called, bet you they don't know, why, because actually they are not interested in the patient. A lot of my colleagues especially surgeons do it for their own gratification, there attitude is look how good my surgery is, look what I have done for you. Most would also rather do a private session as spend time at home with their kids, why? greed for more money.

Please don't come the oh its a hard life, its not, I have never seen a poor doctor with all those student debts, thats just laughable.

Saying that, I agree that the pension was something that went with the job and no one should start changing terms and conditions years down the line.

Sense at last! ... Well apart from the last line :)
 
London Headshots said:
How can you presume to know the personal feelings of an infinite variety of people working a single role? You can't.

I think you just answered your own argument.
 
Back
Top