weekly Seaodyssey's 52ers for 2018 Week51 Party

The first shoe shot I agree with Allan better composition, but I really like the colours in the second shot, especially the well defined shadow they make.

The third shot of Dudley is simply excellent, the focus on the eye really works well. What a cracking little dog:)
 
2nd shot of elegant for me, the shadow on the floor helps it stand out. The 2nd pair in the 1st composition would work I think.

Dudley, a lovely looking dog, #2 without the lead on, but I do like #3 with the inclusion of the letterbox.
 
I'd go with the first elegant photo, I find the angle a bit unusual in the second.
Lovely photos of your dog, may be the slight hint of a shoehorn, agree with the above that the third is probably the pick.
 
Home - I knew I wouldn't be the only one posting a doggy this week. Number 3 for me. I like the closer crop and the little glint in his eye. Number 1 is much weaker in my eyes as you can't see Dudley's eyes.
 
sirch said:
I'd go with the first elegant photo, I find the angle a bit unusual in the second.
Lovely photos of your dog, may be the slight hint of a shoehorn, agree with the above that the third is probably the pick.
Click to expand...
Hi Chris

What is the slight hint you are getting of a shoehorn? just womdering.

Pete
 
Hi Pete,

Derelict - I'm going to say the colour version too, for much the same reason as you. But I think If they were both colour, I would have gone #2 due to having the arch of the window in the shot too.

Elegant - Shoes2 for me. The reds and golds are excelent, and there are no distractions. Stunning.

Home - Leftfield, we like leftfield... I think the second for me, due to the extra context.
 
Round
The second photo is more interesting for me.
It might be because I'm looking on my phone, does it need a white balance adjustment, it looks a little warm.
 
both work for the theme but number two for me also, i do agree with the white balance adjustment mentioned above too
 
Two good subjects for the them, second for me too mainly because it is a different take on the theme
 
LC2 said:
#2, Leading lines - tick, well controlled exposure - tick, on theme - tick, strong colours - tick. But oddly I think I prefer #1, because it's something different/unusual.
Click to expand...

Thank you for your comments

Nostromo said:
Round
The second photo is more interesting for me.
It might be because I'm looking on my phone, does it need a white balance adjustment, it looks a little warm.
Click to expand...

Allan.H said:
both work for the theme but number two for me also, i do agree with the white balance adjustment mentioned above too
Click to expand...

Thank you both for your comments, re the white balance, It was taken early in the morning and the lens I used has a more yellow coating than my nikon lenses and is a bit older so the coatings may not be so colour neutral.

sirch said:
Two good subjects for the them, second for me too mainly because it is a different take on the theme
Click to expand...

michael23 said:
Certainly #2 for me Pete, a perfect location for the theme of round, the shadows of the railings certainly have a good place within the scene.
Click to expand...

Thank you for your comments.

Pete
 
Yum yum!
 
Food photography is quite an art it’s all about presentation not sure this is the best way to have presented it the grill doesn’t work for me a plate may have been a better option
 
Allan.H said:
Food photography is quite an art it’s all about presentation not sure this is the best way to have presented it the grill doesn’t work for me a plate may have been a better option
Click to expand...

It is bl**dy hard. but it was cooking, I did try to take a photo of the steak being lift up at one end, but there was not enought light and my hand and tongs where moving. I guess I could have increased the ISO but it was a complete faff due to where the tripod was. Our kitchen is not large.
But the steak was very tasty.

Pete
 
I like the grill but think you could of cropped out the hob bit(ok I am not very domesticated!). Are the mushroom bottom right in focus? I really like the way you have captured the sheen of the juices which I think really makes the picture and of course bang on theme.
 
Bearair said:
I like the grill but think you could of cropped out the hob bit(ok I am not very domesticated!). Are the mushroom bottom right in focus? I really like the way you have captured the sheen of the juices which I think really makes the picture and of course bang on theme.
Click to expand...
You mean at the top, I had not seen that. I had already cropped and rotated the image to get it looking better than it was shot.

Pete
 
seaodyssey said:
You mean at the top, I had not seen that. I had already cropped and rotated the image to get it looking better than it was shot.

Pete
Click to expand...
Yes Pete the bit at the top, oven, cooker, gas ring thingy!

Roger
 
I do get what the other comments about the surroundings are saying.
With the options available, perhaps a very tight crop might be an option?
I want to question the colour. It seems a bit warm maybe?
 
White balance looks a bit off (yellow/tungsten) on my monitor and the angle make it look to me like the steak is going to slide off. Otherwise I like it, the grill is good context IMHO and the food looks juicy and yummy which is the point of food photography.
 
Cooking

I actually don't mind the composition and crop, a little w/b adjustment might be an idea, it all looks a bit orange.
 
Short, like the composition, think I might of tried to pull a little more detail out of the shadows if possible. Fits the theme great.
 
Yep fits the theme not so sure about the composition though
 
My starter for wk32 Forked.

Wk32 Forked Tree Trunck by Peter, on Flickr

Saw this tree while walking round an open garden in Somerset while away from home.
Exposure upped a bit to show the forked tree trunk better.
 
Last edited:
Like the composition, on theme, well exposed looks sharper on flickr in my opinion.
 
Pity about the fence but a good example of a forked tree abit more of the top of the tree rather than the floor maybe but that’s being a bit picky
 
Bearair said:
Like the composition, on theme, well exposed looks sharper on flickr in my opinion.
Click to expand...

Thanks for your comments Roger.

Allan.H said:
Pity about the fence but a good example of a forked tree abit more of the top of the tree rather than the floor maybe but that’s being a bit picky
Click to expand...

Hi Allan, unfortunatly the fence was there not much I could do about it as I had left my Saw at home. Thanks for the comments.
 
Hi Pete,
Ref the fence. Possibly one for the spot healing brush in PS? The wooden fence is fine, but the wires could do with disappearing IMO. Worth a try?
As you say, you've upped the exposure to make the forks in the trunk stand out. It's had a bit of an effect on the sky that's showing through the canopy though. Possibly could have been done differently using a brush to increase the exposure on the tree by itself, leaving the sky and canopy darker (would have helped make the tree pop too).
It's always going to be difficult with so much of the same colour palette.
 
LC2 said:
Hi Pete,
Ref the fence. Possibly one for the spot healing brush in PS? The wooden fence is fine, but the wires could do with disappearing IMO. Worth a try?
As you say, you've upped the exposure to make the forks in the trunk stand out. It's had a bit of an effect on the sky that's showing through the canopy though. Possibly could have been done differently using a brush to increase the exposure on the tree by itself, leaving the sky and canopy darker (would have helped make the tree pop too).
It's always going to be difficult with so much of the same colour palette.
Click to expand...


Thanks Tim for your comments. I will give your suggestions a try, with my limited PS Skills.

Pete
 
Fork

Good idea using the fork of a tree. The edit is better.
 
Nostromo said:
Fork

Good idea using the fork of a tree. The edit is better.
Click to expand...

Thanks Dominic
When I saw it I knew I had a photo for the theme. Also first time I had used the tools LC2 mentioned in PS so I'm glad you prefered it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top