Hi Sarah - Catch up , as promised.
This is relating to post #107, and is purely my opinion.
First of all - there's nowt 'wrong' with any of these - they are all stunning and I'm nit picking, but your photography has come on soooo much, there are only 'nits' to pick at.
Surfaces: I love this. I don't think it needs any more light on the bottom of the strawberry. What makes it for me is the colours of the strawberry in the fractured reflection at the surface. Lovely.
Transform: I think you've done a stunning technical job on this, my slight niggles are the top hand doesn't look very comfortable holding the pencil and the bottom hand looks as though it's about to draw on the other cuff


But, looking at Escher's version, his hands don't look very comfortably placed either!! It takes me right back to 'O' Level Art trying to do decent pencil drawings of hands.
Grace: Well done - your persistence has paid off handsomely. This made me smile because it looks as though the hover has just 'walked' into space.
Ingredients: I think you were hard on yourself when you originally did Ingredients, but I know that feeling when you can only see the 'flaws' or 'if onlys' in your own work. You've caught a terrific splash here with the cream well lit with subtle highlights. Yes, I'd take out the two hard bright spots on the lower right of the strawberry. Did you use cream or milk? The strawberry looks very slightly soft to me but you've done such a good job on getting the splashes really sharp I don't think it matters.
and finally,
Week 36, Project: What can I say? Excellent - you got there.

I like both versions - the sense of space in the first and the greater detail in the second. People who moan about not having the 'right' kit should read your thread and feel inspired (me included!)
Sorry for the long post ...
Jean