Nikon V1 (or J1) owners opinions?

smc8788

Suspended / Banned
Messages
7
Edit My Images
Yes
I've been thinking about getting myself a Nikon V1 lately, and while I've read all the reviews and tried one out a few times in a store, I thought it would be a good idea to hear some opinions from people who actually own one. If you do own one (or the J1, since they're near enough the same camera), are you happy with it, and do you enjoy using it? I'm mainly trying to find out if there are any major annoyances/faults I should know about before I buy one, that I wouldn't be able to find out from a quick test drive in a shop.
 
Last edited:
I've been thinking about getting myself a Nikon V1 lately, and while I've read all the reviews and tried one out a few times in a store, I thought it would be a good idea to hear some opinions from people who actually own one. If you do own one (or the J1, since they're near enough the same camera), are you happy with it, and do you enjoy using it? I'm mainly trying to find out if there are any major annoyances/faults I should know about before I buy one, that I wouldn't be able to find out from a quick test drive in a shop.

They do nothing for me so can't really help but this thread might give you some useful info.
 
I'd own one if I wasn't hanging on to see what the Olympus OM thing is all about but there's a review here that's definitely worth reading.
 
Last edited:
I'd own one if I wasn't hanging on to see what the Olympus OM thing is all about but there's a review here that's definitely worth reading.

Thanks, that was a good read and just the sort of thing I was looking for.

The only other camera I was really considering was the NEX-7 (the m4/3 cameras don't really do much for me), but I was really after something fairly compact, and the big E-mount lenses are a big turn off for me (as well as the price/lack of availability!).
 
I use a full frame nikon, but have been having a shoulder and arm issue. I've been thiniking of going to the V1 with the 10-100. I shoot everything, anywhere, I just enjoy shooting and think this may fit the bill. I do shoot RAW ande use lightroom 3.6 - Does it support the4 V1? My other thoughts were the X100, but the focus issues I've heard of and being a fixed lens has me re-thinking that choice- I was also thinking of the Pen EP-3, but from what I've read the V1 should be able to do the job and I like Nikon in general.
I know we could talk specs all day long - does anyone have any real world thoughts - this would be my go to camera and the full frame would be retired -

thanks
 
I've been thinking about getting myself a Nikon V1 lately, and while I've read all the reviews and tried one out a few times in a store, I thought it would be a good idea to hear some opinions from people who actually own one. If you do own one (or the J1, since they're near enough the same camera), are you happy with it, and do you enjoy using it? I'm mainly trying to find out if there are any major annoyances/faults I should know about before I buy one, that I wouldn't be able to find out from a quick test drive in a shop.

You really need to use one properly. It does things differently, it does things no other camera can, and it does them better than the bare specs might lead you to believe.

There's a review of the V1 alongside several other CSC cameras* in the next edition of Advanced Photographer magazine, out in a couple of weeks.

* Olympus E-P3, Samsung NX200, Panasonic GX1
 
The problem with the camera is that it looks terrible on paper. Small sensor, minimal controls, little in the way of on-body customisation... The list goes on. The anonymisers on the Internet we're quick to dismiss it as a white elephant, a folly with a short shelf life, no competition for the micro four thirds or the Nex.

However, you have to see what it brings to the table instead. If Nex7 is the resolution king, then the V1 is the speed. if I told you there was a compact camera out there with a sensor twice the size of the X10, G12 or D-Lux... with DSLR focus speed..... Instant shutter response... and an SLR size buffer which shoots RAW quicker than a D90.. A 100% viewfinder with plenty of eye relief... with a 300mm lens that's as sharp as the 70-300VR that weighs as little as a 50 prime... Well, there's plenty of folks that would take notice.

Instead, the forums are full of 'but you can't get bokeh' criticisms. Of course you can get OOF areas, you can do it with any lens at any focal length within reason, if you compose well. Most people on here can get bokeh from a compact, and the sensor in the V1 is twice the size, making the job much easier. I wonder sometimes whether certain forums are full of vociferous newbies, thrilled with their first minimal depth of field shot from their first fast prime, who don't realise there's much more to photography than minimal depth of field shots, but that's just me...

Anyway, the other reasons most cite for a larger sensor is high ISO capability, but the V1 performs well up to 1600 and very decently at 3200.

The two zooms are great, nice and sharp, but the 10mm prime brings little to the table other than an extremely compact form factor. This is Nikon, though, and you can guarantee they will release more lenses for the system; unlike micro four thirds, they have been a lens manufacturer for longer than they have been making cameras. Still, buy a V1 for what it is now rather than what it might be.

The main issue is that the Auto settings often choose lower ISO and slower shutter speeds over fast action. This is at odds with the V1's speed ethos, and Nikon do need to issue a firmware fix which allows DSLR-like control of the auto ISO settings. If you're experienced enough, you can get around this easily by either selecting the ISO manually or shooting shutter priority. Either of these changes requires a trip through the settings menu: it's not difficult, but there's no on body controls to make it instant.

The major advantage for a Nikon shooter is the FT1 adapter. This means you can share interchangeable lenses between your SLR and your compact camera, which for me is huge. I prefer tele to wide, so I don't miss a 24, but at the moment 28 is your widest native option. However, my 50/1.4 becomes a 135/1.4 (with a wonderfully tiny depth of field, bokeh-requirers), my 70-300VR becomes a 180-810mm VR with f/5.6 at the long end. Couple the 810mm/5.6 with VR and fast centre point, phase detect, autofocus as fast as an SLR in good light, and you can see why the V1 is becoming a secret weapon for wildlife..

Don't buy one on spec, for some a Nex or G3 will be the better option. It is expensive, it is still early in its life, but for the Nikon owner looking for speed and telephoto options it offers something no other compact can.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for that Dan, lots of useful info there. I was one of those who initially wasn't very impressed with the 1 series when I saw the spec sheet, however once I started thinking about it and saw how well the camera performed in tests I quickly changed my mind. For me, having greater DOF is actually beneficial in most instances for the sort of photography I do (plus I'm sure at some point we've all tried to get indoor shots at a wide aperture but struggled to get everything in focus), and the only time I would absolutely want a shallower DOF is for the odd portrait, but hopefully Nikon will release a fast ~85mm equivalent prime which would be perfect, even with a smaller sensor.

You really need to use one properly. It does things differently, it does things no other camera can, and it does them better than the bare specs might lead you to believe.

There's a review of the V1 alongside several other CSC cameras* in the next edition of Advanced Photographer magazine, out in a couple of weeks.

* Olympus E-P3, Samsung NX200, Panasonic GX1

Thanks, I will try to keep an eye out for that. I don't suppose you happen to know how well each of those cameras fared in the tests, and which came out on top?
 
Last edited:
Thanks for that Dan, lots of useful info there. I was one of those who initially wasn't very impressed with the 1 series when I saw the spec sheet, however once I started thinking about it and saw how well the camera performed in tests I quickly changed my mind. For me, having greater DOF is actually beneficial in most instances for the sort of photography I do (plus I'm sure at some point we've all tried to get indoor shots at a wide aperture but struggled to get everything in focus), and the only time I would absolutely want a shallower DOF is for the odd portrait, but hopefully Nikon will release a fast ~85mm equivalent prime which would be perfect, even with a smaller sensor.



Thanks, I will try to keep an eye out for that. I don't suppose you happen to know how well each of those cameras fared in the tests, and which came out on top?

Well yes I do, because I wrote it ;) But it's not for me to say - you'll have to buy the magazine.

The difference between magazines and most free websites is that mags do proper comparison tests, and that takes a lot of time and money.
 
Well yes I do, because I wrote it ;) But it's not for me to say - you'll have to buy the magazine.

Haha thanks, I'll make sure I buy it in that case (and I'll know who to ask if I have any questions then :p)
 
There's a review of the V1 alongside several other CSC cameras* in the next edition of Advanced Photographer magazine, out in a couple of weeks.

* Olympus E-P3, Samsung NX200, Panasonic GX1

Excellent balanced review Richard. Anyone considering a V1 or J1, or one of the other reviewed cameras, should make sure they read your findings.
 
Excellent balanced review Richard. Anyone considering a V1 or J1, or one of the other reviewed cameras, should make sure they read your findings.

Cheers Paul - not seen the mag myself yet!
 
Had a quick go on the V1 today and I was pretty impressed. It's a little bit bigger than I expected it to be, not any smaller than M4/3rds so was disappointed on that front, but the build seemed solid and the EVF was nice and big and clear. I went in to try out the Fuji X10 and the OVF on that is pretty useless unless you're shooting in strong sunlight. Might have been imagining it but the main LCD screen on the back of V1 seemed to be very responsive too with less lag?? The biggest problem is the price though... I'd consider it if it was ~£400 with kit lens, not £750!
 
Back
Top