has anyone got the tilt shift lens, 24mm pc-e? I'm thinking of getting it for landscapes but after trawling around flickr searching for images taken with it i cant say i'm that impressed over what the fixed wide angles can do. Any feedback on it would be helpful.
I do !, and shoot with it on my D800E.
So my feedback is as follows:
1) There is a limitation which I have mentioned on here before about the design of the 24mm PC-E and the D800/E which means you can't rotate the lens on it's axis to change the shift to be left to right (rather then vertical) when the camera is in a normal (landscape) orientation. This is due to the rear tensioning screws for the movements striking the overhang of the prism. It isn't an issue with the D3/s, D3x or D4 as the shape is different - nor is it an issue with the 45mm or 85mm which have those further out from the lens mount.
For me this isn't as much of an issue as I tend to use the 24mm in the orientation that works on the D800 for my landscapes, and if I needed to shoot a vertical orientation with vertical shift then I could always go to a different body and sacrifice some MP for the full function.
2) If you use the 24mm PC-E as a 24mm without using the tilt or shift movements then you'll see no benefit above using a standard fixed wide angle lens whether that is a 24mm f/1.4 or otherwise especially at typical landscape apertures (i.e. not wide open).
3) If you use shift either to sort out converging verticals, or to enable you to shoot multiple frames to stitch from a single fixed tripod/camera position then you'll get a benefit above a fixed wide angle
4) If you use shift, and the
Scheimpflug principle , then you'll also see a benefit - either to alter the plane of focus to give you a look to your image that you can't achieve with a fixed prime where the plane of focus is always parallel to the plane of the sensor, and/or to enable you to shoot with a good depth of field at a lower aperture and reduce your risk of loss of detail due to diffraction (which of course defeats the benefit of a 36MP sensor and the lack of an AA filter if you have the E) at f/22-f/32 for example or whatever range your body/lens combination starts to deteriorate at.
Now I don't trawl Flikr and so I can't comment on what you will have seen and I can't point you to anything (of my own of others) that might convince you of the fact. But the lens is used by landscape photographers for the reasons mentioned above, and it is a very high quality optic in it's own right.
I hope this helps.