Hiya James,
Well done on the catch up
Chaos: I had to laugh at this one because of the way the cow seems to be tickled under the chin by what looks like a fibre optic type of light

Indeed a very chaotic shop window. Well spotted.
Finish: Right on theme there, although I think the background could do with some fine tuning/cloning, especially on the right and behind the tomato sauce container. Otherwise I think the background compliments the image well.
Trio: Agree with Lynne, nothing pathetic about it at all and you have done well to get the right exposure so as not to blow the lights of the flames. The colours are lovely. Once again agree with Lynne about the symmetry (possibly also my OCD) and also I would have perhaps given the rims a bit of a wipe and positioned the tea lights straight in the holders (me being nit picky again

).
Otherwise I think you have done well.
Cheers
Dawn