Lens Test - what to do ...

Mozziephotography

Suspended / Banned
Messages
1,850
Name
Stephen
Edit My Images
Yes
Managed to get hold of a Nikon 12-24mm lens at last ... a part-exchange from MPB (very happy with the process) With varying reviews from zero to hero for this lens, what should I do to "test" that it is in good working order and does what it says on the tin.
I know that I have to take some photos, but what should I be looking out for to ensure that it is okay.
 
Brick wall. Tripod. Wide end, long end and in the middle. Shoot the widest aperture but also stop down progressively.

At the widest aperture check for soft corners or one side being soft, particularly if this flips to the other side at the opposite end of the focal range.

If all ok, conpare the stopped down shots so you know the sweet spot of the lens for future reference.
 
Just go out and use it you'll soon know if it is up to the job! Saves wasting an afternoon taking pictures of a wall!

But spending 10 minutes taking pictures of a wall lets you know immediately if you should return a dud lens.

It also saves you wasting valuable time in the field messing up real photo opportunities if the lens is decentered.

Personally I like to know the equipment is going to work when I drive 5 hours somewhere and used up holiday and spent money on fuel and accommodation!
 
Promise to find a wall this afternoon, IF the weather lightens up AND I'll be out for the landscapes on Sunday. Thanks both of you, your comments are much appreciated.
 
Promise to find a wall this afternoon, IF the weather lightens up AND I'll be out for the landscapes on Sunday. Thanks both of you, your comments are much appreciated.

A wall is not a good test target, especially with wide-angles. If the lens has some field curvature, which is very unlikely to be an issue in practise, it may show up as a problem when it isn't. Wide-angles are more prone to field curvature. The other thing is that positioning is critical and you must be exactly square to the wall. With a wide-angle you'll be very close (another less than ideal condition) and it's actually very hard to get the necessary precision - impossible hand-held. If the camera is just a mm out, that'll mean all the corners will all be at different distances completely invalidating the results.

Here a much easier and more reliable test. Good light, decently fast shutter speeds at lowest f/number, keep the sun behind you and choose and a subject up the road like a road sign or car number plate. Focus carefully with centre AF point, then lock focus (switch AF to M, and be careful not to nudge the focusing ring). Then shoot four pictures with the target positioned in all four corners of the frame. It must be exactly the same distance from the corner in all cases, and make sure the light doesn't change - watch for clouds.

Compare images - you can often do this well enough by zooming in on the LCD. What you're looking for is a consistent standard of sharpness, not necessarily a high standard - this is a very tough test so don't expect that. If all four corners look pretty much the same, then the lens elements are properly centred and that covers 90% of potential problems (eg if the lens has taken a knock). If you have to look twice to check the differences, then there's unlikely to be a significant problem. All lenses vary a bit, but if there is something wrong it'll be obvious :)
 
Last edited:
But spending 10 minutes taking pictures of a wall lets you know immediately if you should return a dud lens.

It also saves you wasting valuable time in the field messing up real photo opportunities if the lens is decentered.

Personally I like to know the equipment is going to work when I drive 5 hours somewhere and used up holiday and spent money on fuel and accommodation!

Yes because every time anyone takes a camera out it involves time off work and a five hour trip lol.
 
Back
Top