Donna Nook is one of my very favourite wildlife photography destinations. This weekend was the fifth weekend I have spend at the colony over the last three years.
I vividly remember the first two days I spend at the colony in 2007. I had been told about the two different colonies; the beach and the dunes colony, but expected neither to be as good as they were, photography or pure experience wise.
In terms of the dunes, I expected the seals to be much further from the fence than they were and they were packed in a lot more tightly than I expected. I did see one photographer cross the newly-installed double fence into the sanctuary in an attempt to get closer than the seals but after a stern word he stopped. Luckily, I have not seen this behaviour since in my further 4 visits.
The beach colony seemed, if anything, even better. Seals packed tens deep for thousands of meters down the beach was the order of the day. With a generous helping of caution and respect, in the form of an hour long crawl to the side of the colony, photographers could get about 5 meters from completely unconcerned seals.
In these perfect photographic conditions, and despite the bad weather, I bagged many of what were my best shots at the time. The following year (2008) the experience was repeated over two weekends, firmly cementing Donna Nook as one of my top locations.
Now things have changed.
Arriving at Sunrise on Saturday the 7th of November I was full of optimism. On my previous three visits the weather had ranged from dire to bad, but this weekend the light seemed perfect.
Myself and my two colleagues arrived at the beach colony just before sunrise finding more seals than we had ever seen at the site before, packed in for over a mile down the beach.
We unpacked our bags a good distance from the colony and proceeded to crawl along the shore to the edge of the colony. After about 45 minutes we were around 10 meters from a few completely unconcerned seals; some of whom were even moving towards us. We were bagging good shot after good shot and perfectly happy with our exploits. Soon this changed.
We glanced back towards the car park and saw wave after wave of photographers heading towards the colony. The colony is easily large enough to accommodate the whims of many sensible photographers. Unfortunately, these photographers did not act sensibly. A crowd of around five photographers instantly descended upon our position walking at speed. Unsurprisingly, the seals instantly vanished leaving the seals stressed and us red faced with a group of completely unrepentant photographers who seemed completely surprised at our anger.
This scene was repeated again and again over the weekend, only relenting when the majority of the photographers left before sunset and before they arrived after sunrise.
Even this did not prepare us for the farce that was this weekend.
On Saturday, we arrived before sunset and again headed down to the end of the colony. This was even more important this time as there was a large number of newborn pups within the colony.
After a morning's successful shooting where we were relatively undisturbed by photographers we headed down the colony at a safe distance on our way back to the burger van. Where previously there had been thousands of seals, now all that was left were the newborn pups and their distressed mothers, snarling at the assembled photographers that were completely surrounding their position, often stood up as close as a meter away using flashes in their faces. If anything is more of a recipe for pup abandonment, I have no idea what it is.
The scene was repeated on Sunday despite us walking down the beach and pointing out to any photographer we could find acting up exactly what the consequences of what they were doing was. Almost all responded rudely and continued what they were doing.
At the end of the weekend, I spoke to Rob Scott - the head warden. This year a completely unprecedented number of seal pups have been abandoned this year by mothers either unable to find their pups after being chased away by photographers, or mothers who have rejected their pups after detecting human smells on them.
I wish I could say that this was a problem affecting a minority of photographers, but in my opinion this was simply not the case. I dont know whether this was because very few of the photographers present this year have been before, or because those that had been before saw others behaving badly and assumed they were able to do the same; if you hide among a crowd of badly behaving photographers, then you can say "its not just me sir".
Since this, myself and another member of talk photography (BobbyBlue) have attempted to point this out only to be met with assurances from every member that they are "on our side". Funny that.
I hope this has made a lot of you think.
I will be posting photographic examples of bad behaviour on this thread as soon as I get back on a computer with these on.
Regards.
Peter
I vividly remember the first two days I spend at the colony in 2007. I had been told about the two different colonies; the beach and the dunes colony, but expected neither to be as good as they were, photography or pure experience wise.
In terms of the dunes, I expected the seals to be much further from the fence than they were and they were packed in a lot more tightly than I expected. I did see one photographer cross the newly-installed double fence into the sanctuary in an attempt to get closer than the seals but after a stern word he stopped. Luckily, I have not seen this behaviour since in my further 4 visits.
The beach colony seemed, if anything, even better. Seals packed tens deep for thousands of meters down the beach was the order of the day. With a generous helping of caution and respect, in the form of an hour long crawl to the side of the colony, photographers could get about 5 meters from completely unconcerned seals.
In these perfect photographic conditions, and despite the bad weather, I bagged many of what were my best shots at the time. The following year (2008) the experience was repeated over two weekends, firmly cementing Donna Nook as one of my top locations.
Now things have changed.
Arriving at Sunrise on Saturday the 7th of November I was full of optimism. On my previous three visits the weather had ranged from dire to bad, but this weekend the light seemed perfect.
Myself and my two colleagues arrived at the beach colony just before sunrise finding more seals than we had ever seen at the site before, packed in for over a mile down the beach.
We unpacked our bags a good distance from the colony and proceeded to crawl along the shore to the edge of the colony. After about 45 minutes we were around 10 meters from a few completely unconcerned seals; some of whom were even moving towards us. We were bagging good shot after good shot and perfectly happy with our exploits. Soon this changed.
We glanced back towards the car park and saw wave after wave of photographers heading towards the colony. The colony is easily large enough to accommodate the whims of many sensible photographers. Unfortunately, these photographers did not act sensibly. A crowd of around five photographers instantly descended upon our position walking at speed. Unsurprisingly, the seals instantly vanished leaving the seals stressed and us red faced with a group of completely unrepentant photographers who seemed completely surprised at our anger.
This scene was repeated again and again over the weekend, only relenting when the majority of the photographers left before sunset and before they arrived after sunrise.
Even this did not prepare us for the farce that was this weekend.
On Saturday, we arrived before sunset and again headed down to the end of the colony. This was even more important this time as there was a large number of newborn pups within the colony.
After a morning's successful shooting where we were relatively undisturbed by photographers we headed down the colony at a safe distance on our way back to the burger van. Where previously there had been thousands of seals, now all that was left were the newborn pups and their distressed mothers, snarling at the assembled photographers that were completely surrounding their position, often stood up as close as a meter away using flashes in their faces. If anything is more of a recipe for pup abandonment, I have no idea what it is.
The scene was repeated on Sunday despite us walking down the beach and pointing out to any photographer we could find acting up exactly what the consequences of what they were doing was. Almost all responded rudely and continued what they were doing.
At the end of the weekend, I spoke to Rob Scott - the head warden. This year a completely unprecedented number of seal pups have been abandoned this year by mothers either unable to find their pups after being chased away by photographers, or mothers who have rejected their pups after detecting human smells on them.
I wish I could say that this was a problem affecting a minority of photographers, but in my opinion this was simply not the case. I dont know whether this was because very few of the photographers present this year have been before, or because those that had been before saw others behaving badly and assumed they were able to do the same; if you hide among a crowd of badly behaving photographers, then you can say "its not just me sir".
Since this, myself and another member of talk photography (BobbyBlue) have attempted to point this out only to be met with assurances from every member that they are "on our side". Funny that.
I hope this has made a lot of you think.
I will be posting photographic examples of bad behaviour on this thread as soon as I get back on a computer with these on.
Regards.
Peter
