Did i edit this alright?

[1bpk]

The original

Edited

 

[1bpk]

Too much contrast on the person and rocks?

 

[CSB]

Editing looks ok to me. Caption should read "Those discount parachutes don't work!"

 

[andiphoto]

looks good to me... and like the caption sam lol

 

[swanseamale47]

Editing looks ok to me. Caption should read "Those discount parachutes don't work!"

 

[OlyPaul]

I'm just wondering where the guys shadow has gone. I can see the persons shadow that you took out on the rocks.

 

[grey.squirrel]

Fine for cloning but I would leave the shot as is. The original looks far better to me.

 

[Adey]

Fine for cloning but I would leave the shot as is. The original looks far better to me.

 

[EOS_JD]

Original looks a lot better to me too! I don't mind the cloning but the change is the red just doesn't look right.

 

[Blasteh]

Their back is slightly too orange for my taste, maybe back off on the saturation just a bit on the person.

It looks like an advertising style photo

 

[StewartR]

You've cloned out the bloke in the brown jumper quite nicely, but you haven't cloned out his shadow.