Converting to Monochrome

subseasniper

Suspended / Banned
Messages
480
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi there all,

This is my first post on this site so please be gentle.

I recently bought a Canon EOS 40D (oh yes) and have been taking some pics for a photo essay I am working on.

I use Canon Photo Professional to tweak my RAW files then convert my files to JPEG before exporting them to Photoshop CS3.

I am looking to convert my files to black and white but so far all attempts have been disappointing. I am looking for a really gritty look, like the black and whites you see in the essays on the Magnum website.

Does anybody have any advice how to turn my smooth colour jpegs into gritty mono with a bit of darkening at the edges, very gritty tones and blacks that are almost muddy?

Thanks in advance,

Subseasniper
 
The channel mixer or B&W filter are pretty good on CS3. They give you real control on how the B&W conversion looks and if you use them as adjustment layers it means you can keep tweaking them. Then to get the gritty feel try the film grain or noise filters.
 
Or you could post an example image and let us have a play for you!
 
If you want to 'cheat' then download Picasa (it's free) and have a play with it's 'Filtered B&W Conversion'. Surprisingly good results from a one hit process.

Cheers,
James
 
Why not do the whole process in CS3.

Open your image with CS3. It'll open in camera RAW .

Now go to the HSL tab, and tick "Convert to Grey scale". You can now use the Camera RAW controls to adjust the image as you want, including tone curve, exposure,and the ability to adjust the way individual colours are represented in monochrome.

Process the image. Now to add that grityness go to the filter option in CS3 and select "Add Noise"

See how that works

PS You might want to change the way CS3 handles B&W images, by default it uses a 20% dot gain, which is primarily for litho printing, so it can give a result you didn't expect. Under Colour setting, you could try changing this to either Grey Gamma 1.8 or Gamma 2.2
 
Here's an extreme B&W conversion I chanced upon for Photoshop. Don't know whether it can be adapted for other programs. It works well on blue skies and white clouds, but the is a enough control for many effects, just experiment a bit.

Anyway, here you go.

For those that don't know, here is a run through of the Dual Sat method plus Channel mixer. A nice landscape pic with blue sky and white clouds will give the best results.

1. With the Background layer highlighted, click the Create New Fill or Adjustment Layer icon and choose Hue and Saturation. Set the saturation slider to -100%. The image will change to a B&W. Double click on the Hue and Saturation layer and rename the layer ‘Sat -100%’.

2. Again, with the Background layer highlighted, click the Create New Fill or Adjustment Layer icon and again choose Hue and Saturation. Don’t move any sliders, and click OK. Double click on the new Hue and Saturation layer and rename the layer ‘Sat Colour Adjust’. Below the Layer Tab in the Layers Palette is the Layer Blending Mode. This is usually says ‘Normal’, but we are going to change the Layer Blending Mode of the ‘Sat Colour Adjust’ layer to ‘Color’.

3. Double clicking on the Layer Thumbnail icon of the ‘Sat Colour Adjust’ adjustment layer. The Hue and Saturation menu with the sliders will appear. Move the Hue slider, and notice the changes happening to the image, not just the sky, but also the other elements of the picture. Make the blue area of the sky as dark as you can.

4. Now highlight the ‘Sat -100%’ layer and make a new Channel Mixer adjustment layer. If there is a 'Monochrome' box tick it, and then set the Red Channel to 100% and the Blue and Green to '0%'.

I like this method over just the Channel Mixer method, as there is only 1 slider to adjust in the ‘Sat Colour Adjust’ layer, as opposed to the Red, Green and Blue sliders in the Channel Mixer.

Now because I had the Dual Sat method, and a Channel Mixer layer up at the same time, I played about with how the Channel Mixer interacted with the Hue & Saturation layers. With the Channel Mixer layer above the other layers, I found that if I set the Channel Mixer to 100% Blue, and the Red and Green sliders to 0% and turned off the -100 Saturation layer, blue skies went a lot darker, and gave me the look that I have been striving for in my B&W landscapes. It can make pictures a bit noisy, but I haven't got as far as noise reduction yet. ;)

You can also play will masking areas of the image off on the adjustment layers that you don't want to be affected as much, but that can get a lot more complicated. ;) :lol:

I had not heard of anyone doing this anywhere else, but apparently Russell Brown, the Senior Creative Director of the Adobe Photoshop team did it before me.

Here's a picture with the effect. Not great picture, but it shows how it can darken blue skies
dsc5365bwsatcolmixresizemc2.jpg


The is also the free Virtual Photographer plugin that can give some very good effects, and not just for B&W. Try the 'Dramatic B&W setting for something similar to all that above.

Picassa's "Filtered B&W' can give good results has has been mentioned, and is good for seeing the effect of different simulated coloured filters on a B&w image.
 
Back
Top