Conductors

archangel

Suspended / Banned
Messages
5,024
Name
Mike
Edit My Images
No
I have been involved with music since a teenager but I am watching the BBC Sunday symphony... Still I can't comprehend the point of a conductor...I have never felt the need to look at, never mind be instructed by a man with a chip stick in his hand...I am sure there is an art involved but in my mind, if you can play the piece of music, you don't need a half wit waving his arms to distract you...just saying :D
 
I used to think the same until I watched a documentary about Simon Rattle at The Berlin Philharmonic.

Opened my eyes it did.

The waving a stick bit is only a tiny part of it.
 
I used to think the same until I watched a documentary about Simon Rattle at The Berlin Philharmonic.

Opened my eyes it did.

The waving a stick bit is only a tiny part of it.
Do you have a link....? My first ever conductor once threw his chip stick followed by a triangle at me once because he thought I wasn't paying attention.lol
 
I've just been looking for it, but can't find it.

I'm sure it was on BBC about 10 years ago.
 
That baton controls every member of the orchestra.
To them, the conductor is god.
Those who don't feel that way don't last long.
 
That baton controls every member of the orchestra.
To them, the conductor is god.
Those who don't feel that way don't last long.

Yeah, that's about it.

The bit of the documentary I remember best was when he'd just joined the orchestra, and remember the Berlin Phil. is owned and run by the orchestra members and they select which conductor to employ, he was running them through a familiar piece when he stopped them.

He asked them to play a passage a different way, but they refused, saying they had always played it that way.

His stubborn but diplomatic insistence was remarkable. This was make or break time.

They reluctantly agreed to play it his way. To me, being ignorant, the difference was subtle at best.

As they played it their eyes lit up and they all nodded and smiled.

Result.
 
As a child and teenager I was a member of a symphony orchestra. In my more senior years I was lucky enough to perform internationally with them. The more experienced I became, the more the conductor began to have meaning. It is hard to explain, but they are the "project manager" if you like. Not that we couldn't produce a fine sound together as musicians, but the conductor managed to bring together all the talent to a single voice, if that makes sense.

They don't merely stand around waving a baton, they are the beating heart of a skilled orchestra. They really need to understand the feeling behind every note, every passage, every orchestral part. It is a difficult job and demands exceptional musical skill.

What you see on screen normally, is a bloke with grey hair, waving a baton. What isn't shown, is the thousands of hours practice where the conductor drills his vision into every single member of the orchestra. It's hard graft all around to get anything like a cohesive sound.

This is one of the reasons why, if you attend a concert by an amateur orchestra, particularly if you record it, it can sound out of tune and a bit messy. Not always, but mostly. Ever noticed a childs brass band sounds out of tune? Thats the reason. A good conductor can hear and correct those issues.

I always considered my conductor to be the grandfather of the orchestra, as such, head of the family. That perhaps puts it in perspective. We had musicians which were far more capable on their instrument than he would ever be, but he was a master of the overall sound.
 
I have been involved with music since a teenager but I am watching the BBC Sunday symphony... Still I can't comprehend the point of a conductor...I have never felt the need to look at, never mind be instructed by a man with a chip stick in his hand...I am sure there is an art involved but in my mind, if you can play the piece of music, you don't need a half wit waving his arms to distract you...just saying :D

Google something like ... "What does a conductor do in an orchestra?" :)
 
He's like the mixing desk at a rock gig.
 
ANY MORE FARES :exit:
 
Back
Top