Thanks Marcel.Captive - a simple concept beautifully executed. Tough and gritty - others may copy, few will better. Fast post too!![]()
Thank you Mandyhello and welcome, nice solid start to your challenge.
Cheers Ruth. Yes that one was deffo not a winner it may transpire i'm a one trick pony !!!!!Hi Gaz
Really like your captive image - bang on theme with really nice lighting.
Your first metal image didn't quite live up to the same standard imo but the second one has a nice abstract feel with lovely rich colours![]()
Thanks Steve.Just realised that I somehow missed commenting on these.
Saw your captive one last week and thought it was an outstanding shot. Great lighting and love the dirt on the hand.
Metal - I really like the shadows and light on the lock, really made me stop and look at it. The manhole cover is great as well.
A great start to your 52, looking forward to seeing more.
Thanks Simon. Thats some very nice words you wrote there !Some seemingly straightforward but effective images here, which ain't as easy as they look to get right; you have nailed them.
Metal#2 is my favourite of the three; I am liking the colour, tones and textures, as well as the lines and symmetry. It is a striking and graphical image. If I were being picky, I would focus on the reflection / water in the centre and prefer it to be one solid tone.
Really liking your captive image too; framing and lighting are both effective; the dirty hand is a nice touch and shows an attention to detail.
Good work, fella!
Thanks Madam Mim.Loving the Captive picture, so gritty
Metal, I like the lock pic but too many shadows for my taste. The manhole cover suits the theme better imho.![]()
Cheers Mandy appreciate you stopping by.Great captive image. The dirty hands make you think you have been captive for a while.
... great idea!!..ThanksVery clever idea, nicely executed!
Thanks you.Very clever![]()
![]()
CheersCan't add anything technically. Nice idea for this weeks theme and love the manhole cover for metal
Thanks Allen.I did try and light in the right places best I thought anyway.Hi excellent idea and well thought out light coming at you in the right direction great attention to detail
no crit needed there
Thank you. Carry on ! I would love to see how you get on. This took longer than I expected but I most probably made hard work of itdamn it...... ive just been shooting a similar shot... great idea!!..
Hi Andy. Cropped close at bottom because I had the keyboard on top of 2 baked bean cans :-(Nice one. A little close at the bottom but well processed.
Cheers.
Thanks for the feedback.Captive - Really strong Picture I had thought of doing something similar kind of glad I didn't.
Metal - I like the lock best but the second one is very metal I like the effect the water gives.
Miniature - I like this. good composition well planned and put together
Cheers.Great shot Garyabsolutely spot on for the theme.
Many thanksAwesome.
Great idea really well executed
Many thanks.HaHa .. that says Miniature ... really nice concept, well executed.
OK, there are minor imperfections/contradictions .... best left unmentioned.![]()
Thanks for that I hoped that would help with the feel of the image.Really good I like how you have a shadow on the keyboard.![]()
Cheers Walter.well thought out and a nice job well done![]()

Thanks Carl. I was happy that it looks quite real. Hope yours goes well, it's all a learning curve.I hadnt tried this before and found it a bit harder to do than what I first thought.Nicely done Gary. Working on something similar but nowhere near as good as your PP work. Bravo![]()
Hi Steve. Thanks for stoppping by.Miniature - Great job on this, getting the lighting right must have been tough and your shadow is a clever touch. Like the letters on your keyboard (are they normally like this or just for the shot)?
Thank you.Very good Gary I like it![]()
Thanks Nigel. re photoshop (patience) gets me htere i'm no expert.Great interpretation of the Miniature theme, wish I was as good with photoshop....![]()
Thanks Phil.A well thought out image Gary, excellent work.
Phil
Thanks for the kind words.Miniature - I like it. So creative. Didn't notice the shadows and stuff till people mentioned it. So, that's quite impressive!
Thanks Emma.Really clever - for the reasons everyone has pointed out!