Hillbilly said:
Thanks very much for that - it's an interesting insight. If it wouldn't be too much trouble, would you mind explaining a few points that might help me (and probably others) understand further how these things work?
[*]How does PayPal's system operate?
PayPal is not a bank, merchant account or payment service provider in terms of a standard PayPal account.
PayPal does offer a service called Paypal pro where a merchant can use them as a PSP. This is where a customer is presented with a payment screen similar to most others, but the payment is handled by PayPal and the funds are put into he merchants PayPal account. When using this service you are covered under section 75 as normal.
[*]Does it always operate that way (I think you or someone indicated earlier that some PayPal transactions are covered by the CCA)?
I stand to be corrected here, but I believe if you select PayPal as your payment option but then choose to fund the entire transaction from your credit card, then you are covered. If you find your account with a credit card as a separate transaction and then pay with your PayPal balance then you will not be covered under section 75. You would have to rely on PayPal buyer protection.
[*]Do any other providers sometimes operate in a way similar to PayPal (I'm wondering whether that might explain the previously mentioned Trading Standards bod saying that a SagePay transaction wasn't covered)?
I would imagine he same sort of rules as above would apply with google wallet, amazon payment system and nochex. Nochex is a bit similar to PayPal that you can pay directly with credit card or with a nochex account balance. The direct payment, you will be covered but not with account balance.
[*]If PayPal and/or others operate different transation types, how can the consumer know when the CCA applies and when it doesn't?
You will know you are using something like PayPal etc as you will have to login to your account.
As a rule of thumb, if you are simply presented with a screen to enter your credit card information, then you will be covered.