Super Zoom Camera Req- Good In Low Light

allie5

Suspended / Banned
Messages
183
Edit My Images
Yes
I need a super zoom camera for use in places where its impossible to bring my DSLR (mainly gigs / concerts / shows etc).

This seems to be an impossible quest. Ive done a fair bit of research and within my budget (under £300) seem to have ended up with 3 possibles - the Canon SX210 IS, the Fuji S200EXR and the Panasonic TZ10. All have pros and cons - Im not really interested in video capability, my primary concern is obtaining good quality images at the long end in low light.

The Canon SX210 seems an awesome little bit of kit -14x zoom and full manual control in a very tidy compact package. I like the "dial" wheel to easily change settings but not been able to find anyone who has used it in situations that Im interested in. I took a few test shots in the store (max zoom, no flash, fairly low light) and it seemed just OK but it was difficult to tell on the back screen if everything was sharp or had excessive noise issues. I use a little Canon Ixus now and it suffers TERRIBLY from noise even at a fairly modest ISO of 800. Im worried I might be headed back down the same path with another small Canon.

The Fuji is £30 more and considerably bigger but with the same zoom range. I could put up with the extra size and price if the results were worth it....it seems pretty well received in reviews but again, none really mention its performance in low light. Does anyone know if the sensor on the Fuji would be bigger because of its larger build size?

Finally the Panasonic. It has a slightly smaller zoom than the other two models at 12x (and to be honest I could do with all the reach I can get). Its main selling point seems to be its HD video capability but that is something Id rarely, if ever use. It probably a back runner but Ive seen some pretty good results on Flickr from these cameras in low light which is why Ive included it.

Anyone got any experience with any of these or can point me in the direction of other models to look at?

REALLY need to get this sorted out as I need it for an event Ive got coming up in just over a week so ANY help would be gratefully received from you lovely people :D .
 
I cant really help with the models you suggested, however I do own a Fuji S100fs and am more than willing to take some test shots!

I have no idea how best to show low light noise comparison!!

What I have done is shoot a teddy indoors, at full zoom on apeture priority (as open as poss - all taken at f/5.3) let the cam sort the shutter and I've manually set the ISO.....

Camera normally takes pics at 11.1mega pixels, however at ISO3200 this drops to 6mega pixels and at ISO10000 it drops to 3mega pixels.

2.5s, ISO 100
DSCF1117.jpg


1.5s ISO 200
DSCF1118.jpg


0.7143 ISO 400
DSCF1119.jpg


1/3" ISO 800
DSCF1120.jpg


1/6" ISO 1600
DSCF1122.jpg


1/10" ISO 3200
DSCF1123.jpg


cont on next message......

Neil
 
Neil thank you so much for that, it is very helpful indeed. Im quite impressed with the noise levels on these - MUCH better than my current small Canon compact. I am concerned that the SX210 will suffer similar noise issues and I find myself leaning towards the Fuji more now. I know its far bulkier but judging by these results I think it might be worth it. I should be able to get away with ISO 800 at my next event and the noise levels seem perfectly acceptable on this setting.

Once again, thanks so much for taking the time to do those shots. You are a star :)
 
What about the fuji HS10, much bigger foacl range than any you have looked at, but asme size as s200exr
 
What about the fuji HS10, much bigger foacl range than any you have looked at, but asme size as s200exr

That one is out of my budget really - cheapest I can find it is £349 cant really afford to go over £300. Ive been looking some more options and its between the Fuji S200EXR or the Sony HX-1 now I think. The HS-10 is appealing but its really more than I can afford. Its a shame the S200 doesnt have a little bit more reach really as I think its low light performance is better than the Sony - but the 20x zoom on the Sony is very appealing. If the HS-10 was cheaper, Id definitely be interested....anyone seen it under £300?;)
 
Back
Top