Star glow or natural light filter recommendations?

[A_S]

Hi

Looking to get a filter, or 2 mainly for the Milky Way. These are the 2 I have been looking at. Does anyone have any advice or recommendations on which would improve my Milky Way photography the most?

Ideally a square filter so I can use on my Laowa 12mm lens

Star Soft Filter 100x150 mm

The NiSi Star Soft filter has been designed with the primary function of making the stars appear bigger in the night sky.

nisioptics.co.uk

Natural Night Filter 100x100mm

NiSi Natural Night filter: for the night, for shots in the city and to make your shots unique. Made of lens grade optical glass for precision Water repellent coating on both sides Reduces light pollution by cutting the frequencies of artificial lights The first (often copied, never...

nisioptics.co.uk

 

[LeeRatters]

I use a Cinesoft/Pro Mist style filter for my night skies.

I've never used anything from Nisi so not sure on those exact filters.

 

[TimHughes]

I’m using the Haida clear night filter. It targets specific frequencies, I think for sodium lights.