Polariser for Fuji 10-24

[nog]

Fuji 10-24 should be delivered in next day or 2, I am getting an adapter so hope my kood P grads will be ok with little or no vignetting. Was going to order a screw on polariser, hoya or marumi probably but, from what I`ve read, wide angles are prone to banding. Any advice welcome, Cheers

 

[Peter B]

I think the "banding" comes from applying maximum polarisation. As the angle is so wide, the massive amount of sky isn't polarised to the same extent all over, and you end up with one area more obviously blue than the others. Couple of examples on this site, but google will get you others as well. http://havecamerawilltravel.com/photographer/polarizing-filter-wideangle-lens

 

[nog]

I think the "banding" comes from applying maximum polarisation. As the angle is so wide, the massive amount of sky isn't polarised to the same extent all over, and you end up with one area more obviously blue than the others. Couple of examples on this site, but google will get you others as well. http://havecamerawilltravel.com/photographer/polarizing-filter-wideangle-lens

Cheers, looks a bit iffy especially if wide

 

[Peter B]

Jacobs own brand filters were reasonable, and there's one finishing here in half an hour http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Jacobs-Di...922053?hash=item1a07e9f205:g:VekAAOxyOlhS5ubS

The same seller also has it at a BiN price of £9.50 and might be worth a punt before spending a lot more?

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Jacobs-Di...098176?hash=item2ee6f1be40:g:2scAAMXQzr1R0Ksl

 

[nog]

Jacobs own brand filters were reasonable, and there's one finishing here in half an hour http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Jacobs-Di...922053?hash=item1a07e9f205:g:VekAAOxyOlhS5ubS

The same seller also has it at a BiN price of £9.50 and might be worth a punt before spending a lot more?

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Jacobs-Di...098176?hash=item2ee6f1be40:g:2scAAMXQzr1R0Ksl

Thanks but missed the auction, will have a google as you suggested ad look at some pics/Jacobs