Is it as easy to calibrate a 'glossy' Macbook/iMac screen to show deep greys?

Naboo32

Suspended / Banned
Messages
3,278
Name
Andy
Edit My Images
Yes
First off, I've never owned or used an Apple computer, but am thinking of changing my laptop for a (forthcoming model) Macbook Pro.

I went and looked at a couple in an Apple dealer's and was able to compare the standard 'glossy' screen with the 'matt' anti-reflective screen. I had mixed feelings about which I preferred and was left with this one question, which owners of the glossy screens will be able to advise on :) ...

How easy/succesful/possible(?) is it to calibrate the glossy monitors to show the full spectrum of the standard 'grey scale' :shrug:?

I have read lots of comments from Apple users who prefer the look of the image on the glossy screen (as I do) because it gives "deeper blacks", but my concern is that it may do so at the expense of darker shades of grey and could make micro-adjustments to re-toning a very difficult thing to judge :thinking:. However, if it's simply a question of playing with the tone controls (which I'm assuming it has) and using calibration software to bring out the detail at the dark end (without losing any highlights), then I guess that I should be fine with the glossy monitor.

The anti-reflective monitor appeared to me to be 'less sharp' and oviously lacking the 'wow factor' of the standard screen. That said, if it's the only way to ensure that I can accurately process my photos to look the way that I want them to on any (calibrated) monitor, then I might just have to go down that route :|.

So, what are your experiences, please :)?
 
And if you ever use your laptop outdoors, you will be thankful of the matt screen.

Go for the matte if you do any photo editing was the general advice when i got my macbook a few years ago.
 
Yes you can calibrate glossy screens on Macs. I've an iMac and a MBP and both have the screens calibrated and profiled. When I got my MBP the matte screen wasn't an option, but if I were to purchase again I would opt for the Matte. Glossy isn't a problem but you have to be a bit careful under certain lighting conditions. I don't have a problem with the iMac as I've it located so the gloss screen isn't a problem.

As far as showing the full range of "Standard Grey" that may well be up to the calibration software you use. By default I use Color Eyes Display Pro which is one of the best around. The problem is it isn't cheap. I have used the new X-Rite software for the eye-2 display ( Not the pro) which also gives a good result. Can't speak for any other software as I haven't really used the latest versions.
 
Thanks to each of you for your comments and advice :).

It seems that the matte screen should be the 'safest' option for what I have in mind (photo processing). Let's just see if Apple make it an option with the release (whenever that turns out to be) of the 2012 15" Macbook Pro :naughty:.

Cheers!

Andy
 
Thanks to each of you for your comments and advice :).

It seems that the matte screen should be the 'safest' option for what I have in mind (photo processing). Let's just see if Apple make it an option with the release (whenever that turns out to be) of the 2012 15" Macbook Pro :naughty:.

Cheers!

Andy

Hi Andy, if you do get a mac this year, look into the educational discount. You can save about 250 on a macbook with AppleCare. It may mean you can get on a photography course effectively for free.
 
Hi Andy, if you do get a mac this year, look into the educational discount. You can save about 250 on a macbook with AppleCare. It may mean you can get on a photography course effectively for free.

Hi Phil,

Thanks for the tip, but I'm not sure if I could pull that one off ;). Living in Germany and not being fully fluent in either the language or the ways to 'get around things', I doubt that I could swing a discount that I'm not really entitled to and a photography course in German wouldn't be much good to me :shrug: (nor would paying for the flights and accomodation to attened one in the UK).

Nice suggestion though :thumbs:.

Andy
 
Hi Andy, if you do get a mac this year, look into the educational discount. You can save about 250 on a macbook with AppleCare. It may mean you can get on a photography course effectively for free.
I think that is just for uni courses though - I work in FE and I think for staff or courses its about 6% discount on iMacs and MBPs. (More on Applecare).
 
Folks, sorry to resurrect this, but I'm using these too sites

http://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/monitor-calibration.htm

http://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/monitor-calibration.htm

To see the darkest shade of gray, I have the monitor now at 50% brightness. This means to me, the screen seems very bright.

Looking through the library, this hasn't seemed to have had a great negative or postive effect on the images contained, but these aren't great screens for these tests and seeing deep grays.

I've emailed pics to my work PC to see if they look drastically different to that of my MAC
 
Back
Top