Gear, bulk and bunkum

wooster

Suspended / Banned
Messages
1,171
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi all,

I've recently got interested in video and in anticipation of some ideas I have for filming this year, I was looking at the Ninja V for my R5 to help me see what I'm recording, increasing image quality, losing time limits and stopping "overheating" issues. I was prepared to splash the case as the advantages seemed huge.

Then I started hearing folks say that you need to add a cage, a handle for the cage, a ballhead for the handle, a mini HDMI protector for the cage, a side handle for the cage and so it goes.

Having bought a camera that felt good to me and whose controls were in the right place to provide easy acces for my hands, and which is a pleasure to hold, I'm not sure how much enjoyment all this bulk and weight would actually add to my videographing experience. I'm guessing this would be fine in a "run and gun" situation but unneccesary and a real chore for the type of filming I'm looking to do which is from a stationary position filming nature and wildflife.

I'm wondering just how much gubbins and weight I would really need to stick on it to make it capable of doing my type of video work. I'm also beginning to wonder if maybe the idea that we can realistically use DSLRs and MLCs for "serious" video is perhaps a compromise too far. Of course, the other option I have is to forget this external recorder and use the perfectly capable video already in my R5 but ....

On the other hand, I wonder how miuch this "accessory" industry is bunkum built on fear. Really, the only thing that I would need for a Ninja is to find a way to attach it to the camera safely and to secure the HDMI cable socket. I'd like to do this without the benefit of a mass of metal around my camera. Surely a mini ballhead, an HDMI ro mini HDMI cable and the safety plastic thing Canon supply is enough? I'm assuming my hotshoe won't fall off and the HDMI socket won't bend over. Tell me it's so!

Has anyone experience of the actual handling of these monitors in the situations I mention and if so, how did you organise it?
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, I wonder how miuch this "accessory" industry is bunkum built on fear.
The process often goes...
  1. I have a problem.
  2. This looks like a way to fix it.
  3. That works.
  4. I wonder if anyone else needs something like that?
  5. Wow! I sold four of them.
  6. How do I sell more?
  7. Advert: "If you don't have this you can't possibly do that".
As I was told during a course on writing advertising copy in the 1960s: "There are two basic drives you need to appeal to: greed and fear. Greed works most of the time but fear works better!"
 
It's backed by whole army of YouTube "experts" as well.

I saw a Youtube video today in which someone -who had been given the product to "review" - was explaining how it was easy to damage a Ninja V by "putting it on a desk" and so you needed this cage to protect the Ninja! The cage clearly did not protect about 65% of the Ninja

So you needed a cage for your camera and then one for the Ninja which attached to your camera cage

Trouble is I dont doubt some of the gear would be helpful. I need advice trying to sort out the facts from the baloney to decide whats good for me.
 
Last edited:
I think it depends what you are doing and how you like to work. I use my video kit a lot in a commercial environment and it gets quiet a bit of wear and tear because of the pace it's used at and the number of times it's used. Before I started using camera cages I had a couple of HDMI ports damaged by using an external recorder, the down time and cost of repair is very high compared to the cost and inconvenience of a cage. If you use your kit infrequently and have time to be careful with it you will probably be fine without it.
 
I have the R5 and Ninja V. As long as the camera stable eg on a tripod mounting the Ninja in the hot shoe works fine.

In my experience the cage helps if you need to add more things like microphone or light.

Beware filming can be another slippery slope especially in relation to sound and lighting.
 
Back
Top