I recall the same stories - there have been many Rodinal equivalents since Agfa left us. "Equivalent" in the same sense as "equivalent" when followed by "focal length" i.e. the same in one respect and different in everything else. In this case, same grain and acutance. Shelf life is another matter. I just found a "will last at least 6 months" for R09, but no idea if it's conservative.