canon walk about... 18-135...17-85...28-135

[westley byford]

as works rather slow at the moment ive had too say goodbye to my L lens collection and 50d bady

i now have a 20d and after bang for the buck, been trawling through FLICKR and seen results from the following lenses, and im impressed with them al, but could you give me user reviews from your experience on the following

canon 17-85
canon 18-135
canon 28-135,

i have owned the 28-135 and didnt think its too bad, but how does it fare up against the others??

regards wes.

 

[odd jim]

I've got the 18-135 and find it sharper with better colour reproduction than the 28-135. Better IS as well, and more flexible!

 

[westley byford]

well, one thumbs up for the 18-135

i did notice that colour and sharpness wasnt as good as the 24-105L, but thats to be expected at 3 times the price, but good to know that theres something better at the same money.

also would like to know if there is any sigmas that are better than the canon 28-135 for the money I:E under £200